Single Family for Sale: 1916 Rutger Street, St Louis, MO 63104

4 beds
2 full, 1 half baths
2,982 sqft
$675,000
$675,000
1916 Rutger Street, St Louis, MO 63104
4 beds
2 full, 1 half baths
2,982 sqft
$675,000
Remove from
Favorites
Add to
Favorites
Add to
Trip Map
Hide Share or
Email
Price:
$675,000
$15,000 - 09/26/2026

Type Single Family
Style 3+ Story
Beds 4
Baths 2 full, 1 half baths
Total Living Area 2,982 sqft
Square Footage 2,982 sqft
Lot Size 0.14 acres
Year Built 1880
Taxes Paid $5,900

City St Louis
County St Louis City
School District St. Louis City
Subdivision Lafayette Square

MLS 25080315
Status Active
DOM 39 days
Nestled on a rare double lot in the heart of historic Lafayette Square, this exceptional 4 bedroom home beautifully blends timeless architecture, natural beauty, and modern livability. A wrought-iron gated fence welcomes you to the second lot/side yard (50 x 122), featuring a brick-paver patio, electronic gated parking, and exceptional privacy. Just steps from picturesque Lafayette Park, neighborhood coffee shops, restaurants, and local favorites, this is truly one of St. Louis’ most walkable and sought-after communities. Rich in historic charm, the home showcases five fireplaces, a grand double-door parlor entrance, soaring ceilings, original refinished hardwood floors, elegant pocket doors, and custom interior shutters. The impressive entry foyer features an original inset mirror and opens to formal living and dining rooms, each with working pocket doors and two of the five fireplaces. A spacious family room with a third fireplace flows into the beautifully updated kitchen with a walk-in pantry. A convenient guest powder room completes the main level. The sweeping original staircase extends to the 3rd floor. The 2nd floor features three spacious bedrooms, a full hall bath, and convenient laundry. The generous primary suite includes a walk-in closet and private access to the third floor—an exclusive retreat featuring a luxurious spa-inspired bath with soaking tub and walk-in shower, an additional walk-in closet, and a private office, library, or 4th bedroom. Outside, the rare double lot provides exceptional space, privacy, and flexibility in the heart of the city. This remarkable Lafayette Square residence offers an extraordinary combination of historic character, thoughtful updates, generous living spaces, and an enviable location. Truly special and offering so much more to discover—this is a home you won’t want to miss!

Room Features

Basement Description Storage Space, Walk-Out Access, Full

Lot & Building Features

Appliances Gas Range, Disposal, Dishwasher
Architecture Victorian, Historic
Construction Stone, Brick
Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air
Heating Natural Gas, Forced Air
Interior Decor Central Vacuum, Historic Millwork, Natural Woodwork, Storage, High Ceilings, Granite Counters, Entrance Foyer, Separate Dining, Eat-in Kitchen
Parking Description Electric Gate, Alley Access, Driveway
Sewer Public Sewer
Tax Year 2024
Taxes Paid $5,900
Water Public
Fireplaces 5

Community and Schools

Elementary School Sigel Elem. Comm. Ed. Center
Junior High School Long Middle Community Ed. Center
Senior High School Vashon High

Price History of 1916 Rutger Street, St Louis, MO

Date Name Price Difference
09/26/2026 Price Adjustment $675,000 2.17%
08/27/2026 Listing Price $690,000 N/A
*Information provided by REWS for your reference only. The accuracy of this information cannot be verified and is not guaranteed.

Comparable Properties Sold Near By

Low
$475,000
$163 / sqft
Average
$579,660
$197 / sqft
High
$850,000
$278 / sqft

Address City Zip Beds Baths Price Sq. Ft. $/SQFT Sold Date
This Listing St Louis 63104 4 3.0 $675,000 2,982 $226 N/A
2205 Sidney Street St Louis 63104 4 3.0 $535,000 3,036 $176 12/16/2025
913 Morrison Avenue St Louis 63104 3 2.0 $570,000 2,810 $203 10/27/2025
3002 Geyer Avenue St Louis 63104 4 3.0 $485,000 3,100 $156 11/07/2025
3446 Pestalozzi Street St Louis 63118 4 3.0 $580,000 2,962 $196 11/21/2025
2806 McNair Avenue St Louis 63118 3 4.0 $499,900 2,788 $179 12/19/2025
2115 Arsenal Street St Louis 63118 4 4.0 $550,000 3,014 $182 11/12/2025
3954 Russell Boulevard St Louis 63110 4 4.0 $550,000 2,994 $184 02/12/2026
6 Benton Place St Louis 63104 3 3.0 $850,000 3,060 $278 07/14/2026
2842 Victor Street St Louis 63104 4 3.0 $485,000 2,811 $173 03/24/2026
4020 Flad Avenue St Louis 63110 5 3.0 $630,000 2,808 $224 05/18/2026
2846 Accomac Street St Louis 63104 4 3.0 $530,000 2,996 $177 04/16/2026
3219 Iowa Avenue St Louis 63118 4 4.0 $475,000 2,907 $163 04/24/2026
3642 Wyoming Street St Louis 63116 4 3.0 $630,000 2,944 $214 05/12/2026
2923 Allen Avenue St Louis 63104 5 4.0 $675,000 3,095 $218 07/09/2026
3659 Connecticut Street St Louis 63116 4 4.0 $650,000 2,839 $229 09/23/2026

Map of 1916 Rutger Street, St Louis, MO

Location Map Street View
Photo of Dawn Howell Winkler
Direct: 636-233-4665
Office
5494 Brown Rd Ste 113
Hazelwood, MO 63042
314-838-8661
Listed by RedKey Realty Leaders, Kathy Bresnahan
$
20%
0.87407407407407%
6.75%
$
$
$
Monthly Payment
Principal & Interest
Monthly Taxes
Monthly HOA
Monthly Home Ins.
Monthly PMI

1916 Rutger Street (MLS #25080315) is a 3+ story single family home located in St Louis, MO. This single family home is 2,982 sqft and on a lot of 6,098 sqft (or 0.14 acres) with 4 bedrooms and 3 baths. This property was listed on 08/27/2026 and has been priced for sale at $675,000.

The 3 bedroom single family home at 6 Benton Place in St Louis is nearby and sold for $850,000 on 07/14/2026. Another nearby 3 bedroom single family home, 913 Morrison Avenue in St Louis sold for $570,000 on 10/27/2025.

Nearby zip codes are 63101, 63102, 63103, 63106 and 63118.

Maris

Listing Last updated . Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available. Walk Score map and data provided by Walk Score. Google map provided by Google. Bing map provided by Microsoft Corporation.

All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Listing information courtesy of: RedKey Realty Leaders

Listings displaying the MARIS logo are courtesy of the participants of Mid America Regional Information Systems Internet Data Exchange

Maris

Listing data and photos provided MARIS and distributed by MLS GRID. Member Participants (and their affiliated licensees, if applicable) shall indicate on their websites that IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed by MLS GRID, and that the use of the MLS GRID Data may be subject to an end user license agreement prescribed by the Member Participant’s applicable MLS if any and as amended from time to time. MLS GRID may, at its discretion, require use of other disclaimers as necessary to protect Member Participant, and/or their MLS from liability. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.